|
|
||||
|
This Month
Month Archive
|
Tuesday, February 28
by
Giovanni
on Tue 28 Feb 2006 12:41 PM GMT
Dear all,
Just to provoke, It seems that the discussion on the free speech here is chained into whether there should be some limits on free speech or not, to speak freely!. I do not think that those who advocate for freedom of speech are free of their will. Since economic, political and military power demarcates the limits of what is free and what is not, we are only speaking what is told us. Anything outside this demarcation is not taken into account and is ignored. It is a rhetoric of liberals (The word 'liberal' has semantically a problem to be solved) that by freedom of speech they make their argument magic. It is a precondition not to speak evil! in a liberal society as to be liberal. So, liberalism itself limits freedom of speech. Because no one cares about freedom of speech, as everbody has been freed long time ago. There is no one in prison in a liberal society (Austria is an exception). Because everyone is liberal whereas we see a lot of people in the prisones in the partly liberal or authoritarian countries, because of the diversity that those countries have.
Mehmet
by
Giovanni
on Tue 28 Feb 2006 12:39 PM GMT
If we find 'bittersweet ironies' in It strikes me as breathtakingly naive to imagine that giving up the right to speak freely means that the government official who controls what may or may not be said will do it in favour of minorities? Isn't it just, if not more likely that governments will use the restrictions on free speech to restrict minority opinion? Unless you are confident against all experience that you can control the censor, then it would make more sense to have no censorship. It is all a question of who you trust, your fellow citizens, or the state. I go with the citizens. And in any event, how can we expect people to move from a prejudiced to an enlightened view if we forbid them from saying what they think. You cannot coerce people into changing their minds, you have to persuade. Make the state the judge of what is best and you make us all into babies.
James |
|||
|
||||